{
  "reviewDate": "2026-10-22",
  "reviewScope": "独立核对原49项及CBC16项量价、内容边界、人员供餐、资源与押金；向主任务提供审计证据，不修改原始资料或部署。",
  "status": "needs_scoped_revision",
  "basis": {
    "snapshot": "本次修订前的65行已发布模型；CBC B13原数量为110/135/160人日。后续主任务修订后应重新生成发布模型。",
    "tiers": ["精简", "标准", "旗舰"],
    "currency": "CNY",
    "sourcesRead": [
      "site/support/budget-base.json",
      "site/support/cbc-budget.json",
      "site/dist/budget/data/coffee-budget.json",
      "scripts/build-budget-site.mjs",
      "wiki/04_咖啡节方案/预算与商业模型_v4.md",
      "wiki/04_咖啡节方案/执行与旅程设计_v4.md",
      "wiki/04_咖啡节方案/风险与审批任务书_v4.md"
    ],
    "method": "逐行独立计算qty×rate；将B前缀行及CBC专属资源/押金分离；将执行任务与已有收费边界对照。未获合同的相似名称只列潜在重叠，不机械冲减。",
    "limitations": [
      "全部价格、人数与场次仍为规划假设；没有供应商报价、合同、排班表或景区资源签认。",
      "范围检查不等于现场容量、安全、许可或办赛资格核验。",
      "本子任务不执行页面、交互、浏览器或生产部署检查。"
    ]
  },
  "arithmetic": {
    "rowCount": 65,
    "distinctCostIds": 65,
    "qtyRateAmountMismatches": [],
    "reserveRates": [0.1, 0.12, 0.15],
    "beforeRevision": {
      "festivalWithoutCBC": {
        "direct": [497498, 1162634, 2323628],
        "reserve": [49749.8, 139516.08, 348544.2],
        "gross": [547247.8, 1302150.08, 2672172.2],
        "supplierDeposit": [10000, 25000, 50000],
        "zeroIncomeFunding": [557247.8, 1327150.08, 2722172.2],
        "resourceIncrementAlreadyInCosts": [26400, 66840, 135100]
      },
      "CBCOnly": {
        "direct": [256650, 415100, 633050],
        "reserve": [25665, 49812, 94957.5],
        "gross": [282315, 464912, 728007.5],
        "supplierDepositExtra": [10000, 20000, 30000],
        "roomIncrementAlreadyInB12": [6000, 9600, 15000]
      },
      "festivalWithCBC": {
        "direct": [754148, 1577734, 2956678],
        "reserve": [75414.8, 189328.08, 443501.7],
        "gross": [829562.8, 1767062.08, 3400179.7],
        "supplierDeposit": [20000, 45000, 80000],
        "zeroIncomeFunding": [849562.8, 1812062.08, 3480179.7],
        "resourceIncrementAlreadyInCosts": [32400, 76440, 150100]
      }
    },
    "passedChecks": [
      "65项ID唯一，各档qty×rate与amounts一致。",
      "原咖啡节49项与CBC16项直接费相加等于总直接费；预备费只计一次。",
      "BR02房务增量仅通过B12计入现金；资源替代价值未加进费用。",
      "供应商可退押金独立于费用，商户保证金不计可用资金。",
      "C36只含C07/C09/C16材料基数，没有再次计提已含正常损耗的B09。"
    ]
  },
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "MEAL-01",
      "priority": "P1",
      "classification": "budget_coverage_gap_under_existing_planning_assumption",
      "title": "基础活动供餐覆盖只有警告，没有进入筹资预算",
      "evidence": ["C21邀请12/20/30人", "活动3/5/7天及进撤场2天", "C24临聘100/220/420人日", "C25安保45/90/150人日", "C22供餐仅100/250/500人日"],
      "formula": "邀请人数×(活动日+2)+临聘人日+安保人日−C22已计人日；假设上述名单不交叉且其报价未含餐",
      "requiredPersonDays": [205, 450, 840],
      "budgetedPersonDays": [100, 250, 500],
      "additionalPersonDays": [105, 200, 340],
      "rates": [80, 100, 120],
      "additionalDirect": [8400, 20000, 40800],
      "additionalWithReserve": [9240, 22400, 46920],
      "recommendation": "新增C37供餐补足，采用上述已有规划假设纳入预算；按名单逐人逐餐核销，包价含餐或同人兼岗时相应调减。保留C22和C37相加的总供餐人日展示。",
      "notProven": "这不是已确认的实际少付餐费。C02的20/35/50个筹备人日不全等于现场供餐人日，不能一律追加；非邀请名单内的讲师、技术员等仍需具体到岗名单。",
      "furtherSensitivity": {
        "allCoordinatorDaysOnsiteExtraDirect": [1600, 3500, 6000],
        "note": "仅敏感性演示，未建议默认计入；若C02报价已含餐或主要远程筹备则不成立。"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "MEAL-02",
      "priority": "P1",
      "classification": "CBC_planning_quantity_reconciliation",
      "title": "CBC标准及旗舰供餐与五天服务假设不能自然闭合",
      "formula": "暂按B11每人1次往返且全程5天：B11邀请人数×5+B14场务人日+B16秩序人日",
      "invitePeople": [14, 18, 22],
      "serviceDays": [5, 5, 5],
      "fieldCrewPersonDays": [20, 30, 40],
      "securityPersonDays": [15, 20, 25],
      "computedPersonDays": [105, 140, 175],
      "oldB13PersonDays": [110, 135, 160],
      "recommendedB13PersonDays": [110, 140, 175],
      "formulaForRevision": "max(原B13人日,邀请人数×5+场务人日+秩序人日)",
      "rates": [100, 120, 140],
      "additionalDirect": [0, 600, 2100],
      "additionalWithReserve": [0, 672, 2415],
      "recommendation": "将B13作为可调规划量改为110/140/175；不得把B02裁判或B03统筹的人日再次加入公式，因为其人员应已含在B11邀请名单。B14/B16暂按本地额外人员，不在B11邀请名单中。",
      "notProven": "B11为人次而非已核定独立人数；到离时间未确认，故不能将此差额称已证实漏付。若邀请人员不全程在场或场务亦在邀请名单，按实际交集减量。"
    },
    {
      "id": "SCOPE-01",
      "priority": "P1",
      "classification": "CBC_supplier_package_scope_gap",
      "title": "CBC赛台和练习区拆除恢复未明确归属",
      "costIds": ["B04", "B06", "C12", "C33"],
      "evidence": "B04原备注只含工作台、隔离及布置；B06仅赛用设备运输安装机务；C12/C33原定公众活动搭撤与恢复，没有明示CBC增量。",
      "additionalDirect": null,
      "recommendation": "将B04规划包明确为搭建、拆除、专属垃圾清运与场地恢复；维持规划额不代表供应商已接受该范围，询价时必须取得全周期包价。若不包，须单列差额，不能以预备费已提代替采购项。"
    },
    {
      "id": "OVERLAP-01",
      "priority": "P1",
      "classification": "conditional_contract_overlap_not_confirmed_duplicate",
      "title": "商铺专项清洁与公共区日常保洁未划清",
      "costIds": ["R01-C", "R03-C", "C24", "C33", "B14"],
      "evidence": "R01-C含额外清洁；C24含额外保洁。R03-C场地新增服务未明确具体服务。C33撤场恢复与B14赛区清洁另有独立行。",
      "potentialR01ExposureDirect": [2000, 5040, 10800],
      "confirmedDuplicateDirect": null,
      "recommendation": "R01限商铺交还时专项服务，R03限室内雨备空间调用服务，C24限公众公共区日常排班，C33限活动撤场后的垃圾外运与恢复，B14限独立赛区。按区域、班次、交付清单对账，同一保洁任务只能收费一次。",
      "doNotDo": "未拿到合同或岗位表，不应因名称相似直接扣除R01、R03或C24。"
    },
    {
      "id": "OVERLAP-02",
      "priority": "P1",
      "classification": "conditional_contract_overlap_not_confirmed_duplicate",
      "title": "赛事统包价可能与裁判、设备和技术费重叠",
      "costIds": ["B01", "B02", "B03", "B05", "B06"],
      "evidence": "B01为未知实际合作及技术管理费暂列，B02/B03/B05/B06分别支付评审、执行、设备、运输安装机务。",
      "confirmedDuplicateDirect": null,
      "recommendation": "优先要求组委会列B01包含/不含清单，已包内容逐行减少；设备赞助不自动免除B06运装维保，设备租赁若已含这些服务也不能再付B06同项。不得把公开赞助类别当已落地免费供货。"
    },
    {
      "id": "OVERLAP-03",
      "priority": "P2",
      "classification": "conditional_contract_overlap_not_confirmed_duplicate",
      "title": "驻寨、研发、持续授权、授课和SOP需交付物拆分",
      "costIds": ["C03", "C04", "C05", "C06", "C20", "I01", "F02"],
      "confirmedDuplicateDirect": null,
      "recommendation": "合同拆成驻店人力、样品配方、持续使用权、单场教学、文化合作、SOP与质量验收、节后回访。C03驻店服务不当然含永久授权或SOP，C04研发不当然含门店独立交付训练；但若实际报价已全包，C05/C06/I01等须按明确包含项冲减。C20文化合作交付不能与讲师/材料重复。"
    },
    {
      "id": "SCOPE-02",
      "priority": "P2",
      "classification": "unpriced_or_unallocated_operational_scope",
      "title": "公共出品、工坊助教、清晨出品等技能岗位未分配到明确人日",
      "costIds": ["C03", "C06", "C10", "C16", "C24", "R06-C"],
      "evidence": "C16只含豆奶杯冰等材料；C06只讲师；C10是专业领队。C24和R06有执行人日但未给点位和技能分配。完整执行方案要求按制作、点单、取餐瓶颈和班次排班。",
      "additionalDirect": null,
      "recommendation": "在岗位清单中明确试饮咖啡师、清晨出品、工坊助教、补料洗消、轮休替补由哪一行哪位人员承担；先核C03/C24/R06已计人日余量，再对缺口询价，不再另设一笔笼统执行费。"
    },
    {
      "id": "SCOPE-03",
      "priority": "P2",
      "classification": "contract_scope_to_confirm",
      "title": "音视频、公开音乐使用和成果版权边界应明确",
      "costIds": ["C08", "C11", "C18", "R04-C", "C29", "C32", "I02", "B08"],
      "additionalDirect": null,
      "recommendation": "C08应明确演出内容及依法需要的公开音乐使用权由谁取得；C29素材授权不等于C08音乐公播权，C05配方/品牌持续授权也不替代。C11只发布制作，C29视觉摄影，C32赞助验收，I02结构化目录，B08赛区影像计分。公共设备与CBC是否同一时段占用须核排程；确认可共用后才减增量，不能仅看到已有设备便扣费。"
    },
    {
      "id": "SCOPE-04",
      "priority": "P2",
      "classification": "conditional_costs_not_zero",
      "title": "需报价或经营假设才能计入的费用不应被总预算掩盖",
      "costIds": ["C13", "C14", "C15", "C21", "R07-C", "B07", "B11", "C27", "C28", "C30", "C35"],
      "additionalDirect": null,
      "recommendation": "保留但明确条件：新增发电/高负荷扩容、饮用水检测或净水、夜仓、公共厕所/垃圾增运、游客运力补贴、额外保险与专业配员、支付渠道与不可退手续费、代理佣金、外部法务财务、税款及取消义务。已有资源或包价核实后才能判定无现金追加；未知不能被解释为零，也不能无依据统一加一笔。"
    },
    {
      "id": "TAIL-01",
      "priority": "P2",
      "classification": "scope_boundary_not_automatic_omission",
      "title": "90天费用不是所有留存产品的完整经营成本",
      "costIds": ["F01", "F02", "F03", "F04", "I01", "I02", "I03"],
      "evidence": "F01内容更新，F02回访培训，F03小批改良，F04模块维护；F03明确不包商户日常销售库存。完整策划要求接收部门承接节后人员、补货、场地维护与合作费用。",
      "additionalDirect": null,
      "recommendation": "将名称限定为90天跟进维护，不宣称90天完整经营成本。常态产品的原料、门店人力、持续合作分账由经营SKU贡献账核算；若主办方承担新增排班或最低保底，必须新增预算，不能用F01内容更新或F03试制替代。90天以后年度经费单独批准。"
    }
  ],
  "recommendedBoundedRevision": {
    "C37": {
      "name": "邀请与现场人员供餐补足",
      "qty": [105, 200, 340],
      "rates": [80, 100, 120],
      "direct": [8400, 20000, 40800],
      "conditions": "与C22合计使用；已含餐合同、名单交叉和未到岗部分逐项减量；筹备远程人日不自动供餐。"
    },
    "B13": {
      "qty": [110, 140, 175],
      "rates": [100, 120, 140],
      "direct": [11000, 16800, 24500],
      "conditions": "B11暂按独立邀请人数且全程5天，B02/B03不重复加餐，B14/B16与B11名单不交叉。"
    },
    "combinedAdditionalDirectWhenCBCOn": [8400, 20600, 42900],
    "combinedAdditionalWithReserveWhenCBCOn": [9240, 23072, 49335],
    "expectedFestivalGrossWithoutCBC": [556487.8, 1324550.08, 2719092.2],
    "expectedCBCGross": [282315, 465584, 730422.5],
    "expectedFestivalGrossWithCBC": [838802.8, 1790134.08, 3449514.7],
    "note": "以上仅适用于上述两项量价修订，其他费用不变；最终以主任务实施后独立复算为准。"
  },
  "CBCSwitchRequirements": [
    "关闭CBC必须同时排除B01—B16全部费用、相应预备费、CBC新增押金及BR01/BR02资源展示；不能只从标题总额减一笔。",
    "B12房务已在B行，BR02资源调用现金只作映射，不再加一次。",
    "CBC关闭时B05/B09实物抵支不能继续扣基础活动现金，关闭后应清空或隔离这些抵支，导出不能残留。",
    "原咖啡节C14/C15公众设备和原活动押金不因关闭CBC而删除。",
    "五期现金在CBC关闭时撤除其付款、押金支付与退还；CBC开启恢复其独立安排，不将可退押金变成费用。",
    "没有新增CBC赞助合同，开关不应凭空产生赛事赞助或报名费；CBC品类排他可能影响基础招商，未验证不得宣称原招商收入确定不受影响。",
    "模块开关、总额、资源、资金峰值、默认三档对照及导出需采用同一状态；保留明确不含/含CBC标签。"
  ],
  "conclusion": "没有发现65行量价或已发布资源/押金模型的确定算术重复。需优先补基础供餐并协调CBC餐饮假设，明确CBC撤场及保洁边界；其余为需合同、排班或SKU才能确认的范围风险，不作机械扣费或虚构精确漏算金额。"
}
